Domestic Violence Research Critique Essay

IntroductionDomestic abuse is a problem in the USA, and the interrogation bind that I am critiquing is get a lineing the effectiveness of screening for interior(prenominal) abuse in health administer pre-screening settings. Domestic abuse is a hard stead for the woman going through it and often times its a hard subject to establish. In order to assist wowork force with this process its important that as health c ar providers we run across the complexities of interior(prenominal) abuse and become educated on how to approach the situation with patients. Through place this critique we will discuss how this protects the patient, how data was obtained, how the data was managed/analyzed, and how it was interpreted. egis of Human ParticipantsThis study is ultimately helping promote awareness/ protection to patients in a health care setting by addressing the hap of domestic abuse in each situation. The study consisted of measuring the localize of domestic abuse in the presence and absence of screenings. The study to a fault compared the outcomes of interventions with women with known abuse from a male with women non receiving interventions who get hold of been abuse. on that point is a need for women to be able to get to a safer beam such as a physicians office and discuss private matters so they dont feel threatened. Most women gestate a hard time discussing any issues regarding domestic abuse they have had because they fear losing something they loved so deeply.DataThe data that was pulled was from multiple sources sources include search terms combined with survey results from dissimilar medical professionals. The investigate articles were used to formulate the questions presented in the survey handed out the medical professionals. The threesome questions presented were Do women patients and health professionals findscreening for domestic frenzy satisfactory? Do screening programs increase the identification of women who are experiencing dome stic violence?Do interventions with women identified in healthcare settings improve outcomes? (Ramsay, Richardson, Carter, Davidson, Feder 2002). According to the study most physicians and sine qua non care workers were not in favor of the screening. Women who were surveyed as to whether they think it would be helpful to be screened at their physicians office were mostly in favor by 75%. other study that researched an emergency departments response to nurses screening for a history of abuse and 53% were in favor.ProblemsThe lack of solid reading and research articles led to more extraneous unsettleds. The research articles in piddle away had lack of information and timber information. There was no monitoring of the quality of items extracted from the information from the medical records, according to this research article. Also another variable would be women who have a hard time speaking up about domestic violence even if it did happen to them, they may not speak about it and it would be a low quality outcome. The article talked about how women who had been abused dealt with the pain of the abuse after and if they sought out help?Analysis of Data85% of women found the screening in health care settings acceptable, which is positive in relation to the fact that women care about their safety. 2 surveys found that two thirds of health care providers and emergency room nurse were not in favor of screening for domestic abuse. The results of the data collected were hard to analyze because the collection of data gained for this research study wasnt solid and on that point were a lot of different variables. At the time this research study was conducted there wasnt a system of screening women for abuse.Findings/InterpretationIn the year 2015 most hospital facilities add it to part of their admission screen. The findings in this quantitative research digest didnt support that outcome. Healthcare providers, according to the data in this study, werent agreeable t o the benefits of having a screening for women for domestic abuse (Ramsay, Richardson, Carter, Davidson, Feder, 2002). There are holes in the data collected as far as to why the healthcare providersfelt like this wouldnt benefit women. There are a lot of domestic abuse cases, and I believe these findings were be wrong many years later due to the fact we prescreen men and women in our present hospital facilities. The limitations found by the researchers included unbecoming research/data collection done by the researchers who wrote the articles referenced in this research analysis. The research presented will set other researchers on the caterpillar tread to find answers to this ongoing problem of domestic abuse. I believe that in the future we will be more thoroughly trained on the signs and symptoms of abuse, and certain cues we as nurses can look for. As healthcare providers its important that we interject when we feel our patient is unsafe. consequenceDomestic Abuse is unfortun ately happening all around us in the USA. Using and building off research studies such as this quantitative research analysis will help us stretch our minds to different answers. According to this research study the women interviewed about if they think its a good idea to pre-screen for domestic abuse. This could have been skewed in a lot of ways, but one situation that makes the most finger is talking with your physician about this problem. Usually people consider physicians offices as a safe zone.As long as they dont feel threatened they tend to open up a slit more. When the research study points to the health care providers that arent willing/or dont want to do the pre-screening for domestic abuse, it makes you wonder if there were other factors involved in their interview process. This study was inconclusive in regards to lack of quality information from the stated research articles. The base of this research study led us to believe that pre-screenings for women being seen in a physician offices arent necessary. The research had obviously gone further than this article due to the fact we now pre-screen everyone in a hospital setting. speechRamsay, J., Richardson, J., Carter, Y. H., Davidson, L. L., & Feder, G. (2002). Should health professionals screen women for domestic violence? Systematic review. Bmj, 325(7359), 314.